Hemlock and Canadice Lakes

Welcome to Hemlock and Canadice Lakes!

Home About Us Contact Us Links Sitemap

 

Barns Businesses Cemeteries Churches Clinton & Sullivan Columns Communities Documents Events Time Line Fairs & Festivals Farm & Garden Hiking Homesteads Lake Cottages Lake Scenes Landscapes Library News Articles Old Maps Old Roads & Bridges Organizations People Photo Gallery Podcasts Railroad Reservoir Schools State Forest Veterans Videos

 

 

 

 

 

Hemlock Lake Cottage Information

Press “Ctrl-F” to search this page.

Surname

Side

Map

No.

 

 

 

 

 

Owner

Lake

1883

Pail

Owner

Residence

Source

Cottage Name

Notes Additional Information Sold to City etc. Most sold to City were delapidated or abandoned

St. James

East

1

No

St. James Thomas Fitzgerald

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1888 Newspaper

 

Fitzgerald, Thomas PO Hemlock Lake res. Town of Livonia 1891 Sold to City $325=$12,229 2024

Kendall

West

65

1

Alfred A. Kendall & Jacques

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Jacques House

36x42, three stories in height and a two storied wing 80 feet in length

Rochester

Foot

67

1

City of Rochester

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Gate House, D. H. Westbury

 

Campbell

East

1

2

Colin C. Campbell (had ice house)

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Permanent residence Sold $27 Campbell, C C cement builder home 31 H Naples St Wayland Dir 1907

Johnson

West

65

2

Calvin Johnson (William Johnson)

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Melrose

Built 1881 toward the foot Greenwood Avenue (West Lake Road aka Kendall’s Alley)

Ashley

West

65

3

Roscoe Ashley

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Clover Beach

 

Baker

West

65

3

George Baker

Dansville, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Lake View

Built 1880

Scidmore

East

unk

3

Matthew Scidmore (Skidmore) (Sidmore)

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Scidmore, W. M. 54 acres PO Hemlock Lake res. Town of Livonia 1891 Permanent residence Sold $45

Allen

West

65

4

M. P. Allen (Mr Peck)

Factory Hollow, N. Y. (Lima)

1885 Cottages List

Fair Lawn

Allen, M. P. 1917 Lima

Chesbrough

East

1

4

Prentiss Chesbrough (Chesebrough)

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Permanent residence $5.75 Where Sullivan Campaign touch on is property

Bauter

East

1

5

Adam Bauter (John)

Lima, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Stillwell Cottage

Sold to Adam Bauter of Lima in 1882

Peck

West

65

5

A. B. Peck (not served by Pail System in 1892)

Lima, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Hazel Cottage

Built 1880 towards the Foot. It was sold 1899

Gillette

East

1

6

Messrs. Thayer & Gillette

Lima, Livingston Co.

1885 Cottages List

Lima Club House

Genesee Wesleyan Seminary Retreat

O’Connor

West

56

6

Joseph O’Connor Mrs

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Inglesby

West

68

7

John Inglesby (Inglesbe)

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Permanent residence Inglesby, John PO Hemlock Lake res. Town of Livonia 1891

Stevens

West

67

7

C. H. Stevens

Lima, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Oak Shade

Stevens, Jacob R. 185 acres PO North Bloomfield res. Town of Lima 1891

Chambers

West

66

8

Joseph Chambers and Martin

Scottsville, N. Y. (Lima)

1885 Cottages List

Foers

Built 1871 towards the foot - Farland, Kendall, Case & Huntingdon - all near Kendall’s Alley

Fitzgerald

East

2

8

Thomas Fitzgerald

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

St. James Hotel

Fitzgerald, Thomas PO Hemlock Lake res. Town of Livonia 1891

Kendall

West

65

9

Alfred A. Kendall

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Greenwood Avenue

The foot - Kendall Built 1872, Chambers & Matin 1871, Case & Huntingdon 1876

Wemmett

East

2

9

Henry J. Wemmett

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1888 Newspaper

 

Permanent residence

Filon

West

60

10

Ezra Sines and M. Filon

Honeoye Falls and Rochester

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Kingdom

East

2

10

O. F. Kingdom (Kingdon)

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Fox

East

2

11

R. H. Fox

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Fox Cottage

Fox, R. H. (Gilbert & Fox) PO South Livonia resident Town of Livonia 1868 Barns & Out Building $47

Parmalee

West

63

11

Irving Parmalee Mrs

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Wren’s Nest (Raven’s)

Built 1879. It is near Octogon (Hexagon?) House

Blake

East

3

12

Bradner Jesse Blake

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Blake, Bradner J. 20 acres PO Livonia Station res. Town of Livonia 1891

Dixon

West

63

12

Mrs. William Dixon

Livonia, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Hexagon

Hexagon built 1873

Cook

West

60

13

J. B. Cook (J. C.)

New York City

1885 Cottages List

Near Octogon Cottage

 

Thurston

East

4

13

John B. Thurston (George)

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Thurston, G. G. 29 acres PO Hemlock Lake res. Town of Livonia 1891

Barnes

East

15

14

Mrs. E. W. Barnes

Wellsville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

General Rufus Scott family?

Stedman

East

4

14

H. B. Stedman

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Stedman, Harvey B. Union Cem Livonia 04 Oct 1836 26 Aug 1911 Civil War, 22nd NY Cal. (musician)

Rider

East

4

15

Sherman W. Rider

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Rider, S. W. p o Livonia Station farmer 10 acres born Ohio August 11 1838 settled 1858

Weaver

West

63

15

C. F. Weaver (near Innisfail?) (same as?)

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Point Comfort

C. S. Weaver built in 1879. Three cottages on both sides of the gulley. Sold to city 1899 .

Barnes

West

63

15

Editor Barnes of Steuben courier

Hornell, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Point Comfort

Editor Barnes built in 1877. Three cottages on both sides of the gulley. Sold to city 1899 .

Morey

East

5

16

Rev. L. L. Morey & Day

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Rev. S. Mills Day Pastor of the Congregational Church of Honeoye 1862-1905

Wetmore

West

62

16

L. G. Wetmore (Scranton, Wetmore & Co)

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

The Highlands

 

Earl

East

5

17

William Earl

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Earl, William carpenter 9 acres PO Livonia res. Town of Livonia 1891

Reynolds

West

62

17

William H. Reynolds

Pittsford, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Chestnut Grove Lodge

 

Atwell

East

6

18

George Atwell

Lima, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Atwell

(Atwell, George W. Feb 22 1852 Dec 14 1920 born Lima, died Lima, NY)

Locke

West

62

18

John Locke

Livonia, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Libby

 

Hoppough

West

59

19

Horace P. Hoppough

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Edenwild

Built 1880. Hoppough, Horace P. 8 acres PO Hemlock Lake res. 1891

Wemmett

East

2

19

Henry J. Wemmett

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Saw Mill

On the point near Hemlock Lake Park

Hoppough

West

60

20

Horace P. Hoppough & Short

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Killkare

Hoppough, Horace P. 8 acres PO Hemlock Lake res. Town of Livonia 1891

Lichendorf

East

7

20

William Lichendorf (John) (Litzendorf)

Honeoye Falls, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Forest Home

Three cottages on this point, Forest Home, Englewood & Union Cottage. Litzendorf, John 1859 1913, Lima Oak Ridge Cem

Lichendorf

East

8

20

William Lichendorf (John)

Honeoye Falls, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Englewood

 

Hulbert

East

9

21

Mary J. Hulbert

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Engelwood

 

Pratt

West

58

21

L. A. Pratt (L. H.)

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Echo Rock Cottage

Built 1881 Above & to the West of Echo Rock

Meyer

West

58

22

C. C. Meyer

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

 

 

Morley

East

9

22

John Morley (Morey)

Dansville, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Union Cottage

Morey, John B. 1836-1905: established J.C. Morey & Sons Nursery Dansville

Coykendall

East

9

23

Cole Coykendall

Canadice, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Coykendall, C Canadice 1870 Census

Masten

West

58

23

George P. Masten

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Emerson

West

55

24

William Emerson Mrs

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Picnic Point

Joshua Powell blt 1879

Martin

West

56

24

Martin & Cline

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Picnic Point

Joshua Powell blt 1877

Meyers

West

57

24

C. Meyers

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Picnic Point

Joshua Powell blt 1880

Pierce

East

9

24

Frank Pierce

Honeoye Falls, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Pierce, Frank M. PO Honeoye Falls res. Town of Lima 1891

Dewey

West

54

25

Thomas Karl and Dillon M. Dewey

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Innisfail Twin Cottages

Built 1879 T Karl was Tenor 1 mile fm Foot

Karl

West

53

25

Thomas Karl and Dillon M. Dewey

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Innisfail Twin Cottages

Built 1879 T Karl was Tenor 1 mile fm Foot

Otis

East

9

25

Dr. C. F. Otis

Honeoye Falls, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List RPPC

Bothwell Cottage

 

Holden

East

9

26

Alexander H. Holden (A. M.) (Mrs. T. H.)

Honeoye Falls, N. Y.

1896 Newspaper

Elmhurst

Minerva was the mother Theron

McQuaid

West

51

26

Rt. Rev. B. McQuaid (Bishop McQuaid)

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List RPPC

 

McQuaid Residence above shoreline on Marrowback Hill

Hayes

East

9

27

Rev. A. W. Hayes

Buffalo, N. Y,.

1885 Cottages List

Killkare

 

McQuaid

West

51

27

Rt. Rev. B. McQuaid (Bishop McQuaid)

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Cottage on shore 1 mile shoreline sold to City $14000 1901

Buell

West

50

28

Dr. J. Buell

Lima, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Buell, William H. dentist E. Main coin Rochester home E. Main Lima 1891

Saunders

East

9

28

William Saunders

Rochester, N. Y. (Lima, N.Y.)

1885 Cottages List

Oak Lodge

Saunders, W S resident of South Lima 1903 (maybe)

Dyer

West

50

29

Solon Dyer (Dyer Brothers)

Dansville, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Rochaway Beach

“Tim Bailey Point” Five Cottages- Maple Hill, Cedar Cottage, Belle Haven, Glen Iris

Tefft

West

50

29

Mollie Tefft

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Maple Hill

“Tim Bailey Point” Five Cottages- Maple Hill, Cedar Cottage, Belle Haven, Glen Iris

Reynolds

West

50

29

George Reynolds

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Cedar Cottage

“Tim Bailey Point” Five Cottages- Maple Hill, Cedar Cottage, Belle Haven, Glen Iris

Coleman

West

50

29

A. C. Coleman

Washington, D. C.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Belle Haven

Built 1879. “Tim Bailey Point” Five Cottages- Maple Hill, Cedar Cottage, Belle Haven, Glen Iris

Robinson

West

50

29

Mrs. Robinson

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Glen Iris

Built 1879. “Tim Bailey Point” Five Cottages- Maple Hill, Cedar Cottage, Belle Haven, Glen Iris

Dyer

West

50

29

Dyer Brothers

Dansville

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Glen Iris

Built 1878. “Tim Bailey Point” Five Cottages- Maple Hill, Cedar Cottage, Belle Haven, Glen Iris

Holden

East

9

29

Alexander H. Holden (A. M.) (Mrs. T. H.)

Honeoye Falls, N. Y.

Newspaper 1901 across fm McQuaid

Nedloh at Wanena Pt.

Mrs. T.H. is mother of A. M. Sold 1901

Manning

West

50

30

Rev. William Manning

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Wood Lawn

 

Spinning

East

9

30

W. F. Spinning

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Spinning, W. T. (Spinning Uhl & Co.) president Merchants’ & Farmers’ National Bank home 99 Main Dansville 1891.

Coleman

West

50

31

A. S. Coleman Mrs

Washington, D. C.

1885 Cottages List

Bell Haven

 

Crouse

East

9

31

James Crouse

Honeoye Falls, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Crouse, James H. farmer home W. Main Lima 1891 (maybe)

Brown

West

50

32

W. G. Brown

Buffalo, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List RPPC

Bell Haven

 

Pierce

East

9

32

Miss D. Pierce

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Brothers

East

9

33

Young Brothers

N. Bloomfield, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Young, Jerome PO N. Bloomfield res. Town of Lima 1891 Young, John W. PO N. Bloomfield res. Town of Lima 1891

Reynolds

West

50

33

George A. Reynolds

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Marcellus

West

50

34

Watson Marcellus

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Rosencrans

East

10

34

H. S. Rosencrans (Rosenkrans)

Wayland, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Wildwood

Rosenkrans, Hamilton S., justice of the peace, 1891 Wayland

Tambling

East

10

35

William Tambling

Cohocton, N.Y.

1885 Cottages List

Liberty

Tambling-Larrowe Cottage, erected in 1879

Teft

West

50

35

Mollie Teft Mrs

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Shady Nook

 

Bunnell

West

50

36

A. O. Bunnell

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Bunnell, A. O. p o Dansville editor of the “Dansville Express.” Dansville 1881

Martin

East

10

36

Amasa H. Martin

N. Bloomfield, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Martin, Amasa H. 129 acres PO North Bloomfield res. Town of Lima 1891

Morris

East

10

37

B. M. Morris (Professor John J. Morris)

Wayland, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Ingleside

Built 1881

Willard

West

50

37

F. A. Willard

Brooklyn, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Way Back

 

McDonald

West

49

38

Mrs. H. H. McDonald (MacDonald) (H. M.)

Fort Pierre, Dakoda

1885 Cottages List

Fort Pierre

(Lawyer)

Miller

East

13

38

J. Albert Miller (G. A. Miller)

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Mineral Springs

aka Sulphur Spring 1878. Miller, J A boards F W Dansville 1908 Rural Route No 4)

Fisher

West

48

39

George W. Fisher Fred Conderman

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Idlewood

Built 1875. Southwardly on this point, you reach Glen Bridge. To the West are Glen Hill & Glen Avenue

Miller

East

13

39

J. Albert Miller

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Miller, J A boards F W Dansville 1908 Rural Route No 4

Fisher

East

13

40

George W. Fisher Fred Conderman

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Cottage Hotel

East Side Half Way Down Large Glen w paths Behind it

Sterns

West

47

40

M. A. Sterns

Brooklyn, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Tanglewood

 

Edwards

West

46

41

James M. Edwards

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List RPPC

Wigwam

Edwards, James M. (Oberdorf & Edwards) hardware 1891)

Fisher

East

13

41

George W. Fisher Fred Conderman

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Shady Elms

George owns Hotel, Fred proprietor

Hatch

East

13

42

H. W. Hatch

Blood’s Station, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Sylvan Retreat

Hatch, Hiram W., general produce, resides at Blood’s Depot. 1891 Wayland Dir

Pierce

West

45

42

William Henry Pierce

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Oneida

Pierce, William Henry & George A. merchants Springwater 1868)

Bronson

West

45

43

Mrs. A. Bronson

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Slaysman

East

13

43

Rev. George Slaysman

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Wallace

East

13

44

Rev. J. E. Wallace

Springwater, N. Y. Olean

1885 Cottages List RPPC

Gypsy Wild

Wallace, James 30 acres PO Dansville res. Town of West Sparta 1891 (maybe)

Ward

West

43

44

Frank A. Ward

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Idle Hour

Built 1884 by G.K., Frank A., & Wm. S. Ward (all brothers)

Dyer

West

42

45

O. C. Dyer & Brother Horatio F. Dyer

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Seven Oaks

Dyer, Brothers (Solon S. & Horatio F.) dry goods & carpets 148 & 150 Main Dansville 1891

Hendershott

East

13

45

J. H. Hendershott (John D)

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Native Land

Hendershott, J. D. mechanic PO Springwater res. Town of Springwater 1891

Ward

West

42

45

Rev. G. K. Ward

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Parsonage Cottage

Ward, G. K. pastor of Dansville Presbyterian Church 1873-1898),

Becker

East

13

46

A. B. Becker

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Acorn

Becker, Allen B doctor PO Springwater res. Town of Springwater 1891 Sold to J H Barnhard $59

Ward

West

43

46

Rev. G. K. Ward

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

(Ward, G. K. pastor of Dansville Presbyterian Church 1873-1898)

Cooper

East

18

47

H. R. Cooper (H. N.) (H. K.) (A. Snyder)

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

The Wilderness

built 1881 $800 = $24,000 2024

Ward

West

41

47

Rev. G. K. Ward

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Interlachen

(Ward, G. K. pastor of Dansville Presbyterian Church 1873-1898)

Crisfield

West

41

48

Dr. J. E. Crisfield

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Point Pleasant

Crisfield, J. E. (Crisfield & Driesbach) 130 Main home do Dansville 1891

Wiley

East

19

48

Robert H. & Henry A. Wiley

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Camp Wiley

Wiley, Henry A. farmer Springwater 1891 Wiley, Robert H. attorney Springwater 1891

Bailey

West

41

49

J. J. Bailey

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Comfort Cove

Bailey, J. J. p o Dansville hardware dealer. Dansville 1881

Redmond

East

19

49

Samuel Redmond

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Honolulu

Redmond, Samuel baker & confectioner 138 Main home do. Dansville 1891

Cogswell

West

41

50

William P Cogswell

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Lakewood Cottage

Cogswell, William p o Dansville lumber merchant born Dansville 1850

Morris

East

20

50

J. H. Morris

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Sunnyside

Withington sold a portion to Grover & Morris in 1878

Hunter

East

21

51

Rev. William Hunter

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Hunter Cottage

Erected 1880 Hunter, William p o Springwater. pastor of Presby church 1881. Sold South end to George Higgins built 1880

Johnson

West

36

51

Mrs. William Johnson

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Built 1881 Permanent Residence

Higgins

East

22

52

George Higgins

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Ashland Cottage

Built 1880, South end of Hunter property. Higgins, George 180 acres PO Springwater res. Town of Springwater 1891

Odell

East

22

53

Charles Odell

Webster Crossing, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Odell, Charles 129 acres PO Webster’s Crossing res. Town of Springwater 1891

Withington

East

24

54

A. W. Withington (A. M.)

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Onnalinda

Built 1876 Withington, A. M. produce dealer PO Springwater res. Town of Springwater 1891

Grover

East

25

55

Morris & Grover

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottage List

Sunnyside

Built 1878 Grover, L. merchant 7 acres PO Springwater resident Town of Springwater 1868

Brown

East

26

56

Murray Brown

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Hazeldell

also see Hazel Dell

Dell

West

unk

56

Hazel Dell

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottage List

Hazeldell

Built 1878 extreme south end of Withington’s purchase. also see Murray Brown

White

East

25

57

D. B. White

Canadice, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Hermitage

White, E. A. farmer 160 acres PO Hemlock Lake resident Town of Livonia 1868 (maybe)

Kellogg

East

28

58

Nathaniel A. Kellogg (N. K.) (M. A.)

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Rudder Grange

Built 1880 Kellogg’s Point KELLOGG, N. A. agricultural works PO Springwater 1868

Parks

East

28

59

S. M. Parks (S. P.)

Bloods, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Parks Cottage

Parks, Spencer 95 acres PO Springwater res. Town of Springwater 1891

Snyder

East

28

60

Mrs. H. S. Snyder (H. L.)

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Sweet Home

SNYDER, H L (C A & H L Snyder) home 1Perrin St Dansville 1908 Sold 1899

Blake

East

28

60

Richard Blake

Livonia, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Vesper Cliff

Built 1874

Barnes

East

28

60

Professor Barns

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Chestnut Grove

Built 1880. Next to Richard Blake cottage. Barnes then sold to Close and Reynolds and they named their cottage, Chestnut Grove.

Thompson

East

32

61

Furman Thompson Mrs

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Edgewood

Built 1879 Thompson, Furman 96 acres Town of Springwater 1891

Jackman

East

31

62

Albert G. Jackman

Canadice, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Jackman, Albert G., for­merly of Springwater, ae 75 yrs died Tuesday, June 23d, 1914, at Scottsville.

Swartz

East

36

63

John Swartz (Swarts) (William)

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Edgewood

Swarts, John G. 60 acres PO Webster’s Crossing res. Town of Sparta 1891

Smith

East

64

64

Daniel E. Smith & Case

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Lake Shore House

Built 1873 Permanent residence Lake Shore House was three quarters of a mile from Jacques House

Smith

East

36

65

Daniel Smith, Jr.

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Smith, D. E. cooper and farmer 10 acres Town of Springwater 1868 Permanent residence $66

Dotterweich

East

36

66

Robert Dotterweich (Dotterwich)

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Dotterweich, Robert manager Dansville Brewing Co. home Liberty Dansville 1891

Johnson

East

36

67

William Johnson

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Permanent Residence Farm House A landing for the Seth Green Steamship was built here 1875

Small

East

28

68

George Small (Smalt)

Perkinsville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Smalt, George, r 55, farmer 100. 1891 Wayland Dir $27

Pfaff

Head

28

69

Frank Pfaff

Wayland, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Pfaff, Frank, resident. 1891 Wayland Dir

Houghtaling

Head

28

70

Charles Houghtaling (Hotaling)

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Hotaling farm is East of the Canadice Lake outlet

Johnson

East

70

71

William Johnson

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Saw Mill

 

Adams

unk

unk

No

Bradley Adams (Hermit)

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

RPPC

Bradley Cabin

After 1883 D. B. Waite book

Adams

West

40

No

Cliford Adams

Livonia

#14 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

Adams, Clifford G. Union Cem Livonia 1886 1945 WWI, Batt. B, 58th Artillery CAC-American EF

Alger

West

35

No

D. P. Alger

Springwter, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Port House

Alger, D. P. hotel PO Conesus Center res. Town of Conesus 1891

Ashland

East

22

No

George Ashland

unk

1885 Cottages List

Ashland Cottage

Also See Higgins

Atwell

West

39

No

George Atwell

Lima, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Atwell

12x12 fishing cabin built 1878 for his trout fishing

Beckwith

Foot

35

1

Beckwith Russell?

Lima, N. Y.

1899 Newspaper

 

Not Sold 1899 Beckwith, A. A. 1917 Lima

Bennett

East

12

No

J. & Guy E. Bennett

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List RPPC

Morning Spring?

May be three separate cottages Bennett, James, resident, 1891 Wayland Dir

Bethesda

East

31

No

Bethesda

unk

1885 Cottages List

Bethesda

There is a fountain. Water from spring on the side of the hill 25 rods distant. High in iron

Blake

West

52

No

Bradner J. Blake

Livonia Center N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Maloy’s Point

Cottage was moved across lake by Blake

Blake

West

61

No

Richard Blake

Livonia, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Vesper Cliff

Built 1874 and another cottage named Chestnut Grove 1880

Bliss

Foot

67

1

Roswell Bliss

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Bliss, William R. drugs and medicines clerk PO Hemlock Lake resident Town of Livonia 1868

Bond

unk

unk

No

Enos W. Bond Mrs

Wellsville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Grove Cottage

Enos was journalist Wellsville, NY

Borden

East

16

No

Isaac Borden

unk

1885 Cottages List

 

Borden, Isaac 36 Posey 43 Early Hist Of Springwater 1887

Brown

unk

unk

No

Alexander M. Brown

Rochester, N. Y.

1896 Newspaper

Hazel Dell

Built 1878 297 ft Frontage Brown, A. manufacturers of spinning wheels Town of North Dansville 1868

Buffalo Grp.

West

unk

No

Buffalo Syndicate

Buffalo, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Tittle Point

 

Capron

East

unk

No

Wilbur W. Capron

Springwater, N. Y.

1890 RPPC

Old Kentucy Home

Near the Half Way House Capron, Wilber W. 1839 1903 s/o S. & L. Mt Vernon Cem Springwater

City House

Foot

35

No

City House

Rochester, N. Y.

#9 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

 

Colegrove

East

unk

No

Colegrove

Canadice, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

Elm Cottage

Harlow Colegrove was the orignal Colgrove settler

Connor

Foot

None

No

Orton Connor

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

 

The foot

Craig

Foot

None

No

Theodore Craig (Craig Cottage & Barn)

unk

1899 Newspaper

The Red House

1899 sold to LC Short $185

Curtis

East

23

No

P. H. Curtice

unk

1885 Cottages List

Curtis Point

Curtice, Ezra N. postmaster and insurance agent 11 acres res. Town of Springwater 1891

Dorr

West

40

No

Dorr Brothers Samuel G & Tracy

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Built 1882

Earl

unk

unk

No

John Earl

Livonia, N.Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Fairchild

East

unk

No

Fairchild

Dansville, N. Y.

1899 Newspaper

 

Sold 1899 Fairchild, Harvey A. clerk 155 Main home 14 Leonard Dansville 1891

Faulkners

West

44

No

Dr. Faulkner

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Faulkners

Faulkner, Dr. James p o Dansville physician

Fogarty

East

24

No

John Fogarty

Hemlock, N. Y.

#3 & #4 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

Fogarty, James 97 acres PO Hemlock Lake res. Town of Livonia 1891

Funk

West

40

No

Funk

unk

#13 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

 

Garsey

East

29

No

Henry W. Garsey

Wayland, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Boone’s

Built 1879 Henry W Garnsey. Deeded to Mrs. Stewart. 1881 addition built. 1882 purchased by Dr. Boone of Springwater

Gillette

West

48

No

Gillette

unk

#17 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

Gillette, M. M. p o Livonia Station farmer. Livonia 1881 (maybe)

Goodrich

East

14

No

Abner Goodrich

Canadice, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Halfway House

Rebuilt 1890

Grover

Head

37

No

Henry T. Grover

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Angler’s Cabin

Grover, Henry T. merchant PO Springwater res. Town of Springwater 1891

Halsey

East

16

No

Mrs. Halsey

unk

#2 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

 

Hazel

East

26

No

Hazel or Dell

unk

1885 Cottages List

 

Built 1878

Idlewood

West

48

No

George W. Fisher

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Idlewood

Built 1875 “Camp Happy, 1872, Geneseo, N. Y.”

Jackson

Foot

66

No

Jacob (Jake) Jackson

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Jackson Cottage

JACKSON, Jacob (Jake) May 1834 - 1901 Civil War. Ex-Slave who travelled north with returning Union Soldiers, settled at Hemlock Lake. Harder Road Cemetery

Jacques

Foot

65

No

Darius Jacques Russel R Jacques ran Hotel

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Jacques House

Jacques, Darius Livonia Twp pg 58 Ontario Co 1820 Census

Jenkins

West

38

No

John Jenkins

unk

1885 Cottages List

 

Built while Jenkins was lumbering. Harvey Humphrey Webster Crossing 1881

Kinney

Foot

None

No

Kinney

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

 

The foot

Knapp

West

46

No

Mrs. George Knapp

unk

#16 1942 Hand Drawn Map RPPC

 

Knapp, G. L. flour & feed 107 Main St. PO Dansville resident Town of North Dansville 1868

Landgon

West

46

No

Landgon (repaired 1910)

unk

#18 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

Langdon, Joseph In 1850 lived in the town of Canadice, NY. (maybe)

Langling

East

11

No

Langling

unk

1885 Cottages List

Moss Rock

aka Tambling-Larrowe Cottage

Lima House

East

6

No

Lima House (One Mile fm Foot of Lake)

Lima, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Lima House

The Lima house built in 1834 or 5, and sold in 1857 or built 1828 sold 1847. G. W. Atwell Sr., Levi Yorks, Harvey J. Wood & Albert Chapman for Sportsman’s Club house.

Ihgoldsby

East

6

No

John Ihgoldsby

unk

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

 

Built 1880 by Ihgoldsby. Near the St. James.

Litchendorf

East

7

No

Litchendorf Brothers (Litzendorf)+E38

Conesus, NY

1885 Cottages List

Forest Home

Built 1882

Marquerite

unk

unk

No

Marquerite (Marguerite)

unk

RPPC

Marquerite

 

McComber

unk

unk

No

Cyrus McComber

unk

1896 Newspaper

 

122 ft Frontage

Metzler

West

40

No

Metzler

unk

#12 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

 

Mill House

Foot

None

No

Mill House

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

 

The foot

Millard

unk

unk

No

Millard Sisters

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Englewood

Millard, H. A. horticultural agt PO Hemlock Lake resident Town of Livonia 1868

Moose

unk

unk

No

Peter Moose

Dansville, N. Y.

1896 Newspaper

 

150 ft Frontage Moose, Peter 19 acres PO Dansville res. Town of Sparta 1891

Morehouse

East

15

No

George Morehouse (Mr Shepherd)

Wayland, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Sylvan Retreat

Built on Long Point for his invalid wife

Mosquito

unk

unk

No

Mosquito Lodge

unk

RPPC

Mosquito Lodge

Built after 1883 D. B. Waite book

Nivergall

West

62

No

Fred Nivergall (Mrs)

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1872 Map 1883 D. B. Waite book

 

Farm House. Fred Nivergall bought the land from Jacques in 1868 and built his residence

Odell

East

24

No

Charles ODell

Webster Crossing, N. Y.

#5 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

Odell, Charles 129 acres PO Webster’s Crossing res. Town of Springwater 1891

Peer

West

unk

No

Peer

Lima, N. Y.

1899 Newspaper

 

Sold 1899 Peer, Alfred, L., Lima St Rose Cem (maybe)

Peer

West

unk

No

Peer Second Cottage

Lima, N. Y.

1899 Newspaper

 

Sold 1899

Pierce

West

45

No

William Henry Pierce & Others

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List RPPC

Onehda

Built 1874 “Grape-vine Point” Cottage taken down. Fruit trees planted

Powell

West

unk

No

Tyler G. Powell

unk

1896 Newspaper

 

213 ft Frontage Powell, Tyler G. 180 acres PO Hemlock Lake Town of Conesus 1891

Robinson

East

33

No

Judge Stephen Robinson

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Vesper Cliff Cottage

Built 1877

Robinson

West

unk

No

Robinson Mrs

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Spring Bank

 

Sanger

unk

unk

No

Sanger, Harry F.

Lima, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Oak Shade

Sanger, H. F. jeweler and optician E. Main corner Lima 1891

Schneck

West

36

No

C. Schneck

unk

#10 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

 

Schwan

unk

unk

No

Joseph E Schwan

Dansville, N. Y.

RPPC

 

He was a home builder

Scott

East

31

No

Mrs. Gertrude Barnes Scott (Toddy)

Wellsville, N. Y.

#1 #6 #7 #8 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

Last Cottage on the lake to be sold to the City - 1949 after 70 years on the lake

Seymour

unk

unk

No

Seymour Mrs

Rochester, N.Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Short

West

37

No

E. Short

Hemlock

#11 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

Short, Ernest T. (Bernice) retired (milk) owns 180a Hemlock T H44. 1917

Spinning

unk

unk

No

W. T. Spinning

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Spinning, William T. North Dansville Last Will & Testament Geneseo Volume 18, page 338

Springwater

West

unk

No

Springwater Cottage near Head of Lake

na

RPPC

 

Octogon House? Springwater Cottage?

St. James

East

1

No

St. James Restaurant Ice House Dance Platform

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1888 Newspaper

 

Pavillions, pump & Outbuildings

Stewart

West

54

No

B. Stewart

unk

#19 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

In 1878, Mrs. Garnesey & Mrs. Stewart sold a portiion of their land on the south end to Todd of Spencerport.

Stewart

West

54

No

S. Stewart

Dansville, N. Y.?

#20 1942 Hand Drawn Map

 

Stewart, Sarah home 19 Elizabeth St Dansville 1908 (maybe)

Stuart

Head

35

No

Stuart Cabin

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottage List

 

1888 - there were 112 buildings, 96 cottages, 5 hotels, 5 residents, 6 cabins 47 barns

Superintent

Foot

67

No

Superintendent’s House

Rochester, N. Y.

1888 Newspaper

Gate House

Gate actually refers to the Superintendent’s House Thomas M Blossom

Swarts

East

34

No

John Swarts

Dansville, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Built 1879 by Swarts, John G. 60 acres PO Webster’s Crossing 1891. He purchased south end of Judge Robinson property.

Tenny

unk

unk

No

Clarence V. Tenny

Lima, N. Y.

1896 Newspaper

 

284 ft Frontage Tenney, Clarence 133 acres PO Lima res. Town of Lima 1891

Todd

East

30

No

Todd

Spencerport, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Waite

East

27

No

D. Bryon Waite

Canadice

1885 Cottages List

Hermitage

Built 1875 Kitchen added 1878 Only free picnic area on the Lake First landing built sour of the center of the lake for Seth Green

Walker

West

47

No

“Crazy” Walker then M. A. Stearns 1883

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Tanglewood

“original” Parsonage 1879 Ward, Bailey, Fielder, Sterns, McCurdy, Parmelee, Dyer, Edwards, Williams, Faulkner, Hedges, Delong, Sweet. Stearns owns in 1883

Wiley

East

19

No

Wiley Brothers Robert H & Henry A

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Sheep Pen Point

Bald Hill farmers had a pen here to wash their sheep each year

Willard

East

unk

No

Willard

unk

1885 Cottages List

Forest Home

See also, Litzendorf

Willow Ravine

West

unk

No

unk

unk

1880 Newspaper

Willow Ravine

 

Withington

West

24

No

W. E. Withington

Springwater, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Octagon (Hexegon?)

Albert M. Withington, then Erie Depot agent at Springwater (maybe)

Woodruff

East

11

No

D. B. Woodruff

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

RPPC 1st Cottage

Liberty 1879

May be connected with Tamblin-Larrowe Cottage

Woodruff

unk

unk

No

D. B. Woodruff

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

RPPC 2nd Cottage

Willow Beach

 

Ashley

West

65

1

Isaac Ashley

Rochester, N. Y.

1880 Newspaper

Lake View

Built 1881 toward the foot, next to James Peck. Owned by George Baker of Dansville.

Fitzgerald

unk

unk

unk

Thomas Fitzgerald

Hemlock Lake, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

Fitzgerald Cottage

Fitzgerald, Thomas PO Hemlock Lake res. Town of Livonia 1891

Holden

unk

47

unk

Holden & Dryer Theron Timothy Holden

Honeoye Falls, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

Banker, Honeoye Falls

O’Brian

West

unk

unk

O’Brian

Rochester, N. Y.

1885 Cottages List

 

 

Farland

West

65

1

Rochester Mayor Farland

Rochester, N. Y.

D. B. Waite 1883 Book

 

The foot - Built 1871

 

 

 

 

Hemlock Lakes Cottage Listing

A surname might be listed more than once. Many Cottages were passed on to next generation family members. Some owned more than one property.

 

 

 

www.HemlockandCanadiceLakes.com