Josiah Short was born in Massachusetts and came to Livonia, NY with his parents when he was about six years old. His father Philip purchased 120 acres at the foot of Hemlock Lake and built a log cabin, the first in the area. Philip later built a large family home, a house that still stands on South Main Street outside Hemlock.
In his early married life, Josiah and his wife Catherine lived in Springwater. He owned land in Canadice (though he did not necessarily live on that farm), an 84-acre property “formerly owned by William TerBush,” where his son Noah later lived. From about 1842, Josiah and his family lived on his father’s farm at the foot of Hemlock Lake. Just a few houses north of the Philip Short property was the home of Mehitabel Wetmore, with whom Josiah had a liaison, resulting in the births of three children.
Josiah and Catherine separated (they did not divorce) in the early 1850s. He went to live in Rochester; Catherine remained in Hemlock.
He wrote his will on September 26, 1857, less than a month before he died. In his will, he acknowledged his paternity of three of Mehitabel Wetmore’s children: Julia, James, and Delia. He also mentions his sons Junius, Noah, and Moses. Son David had already died, as had daughter Mary. He did not mention his estranged wife Catherine; his executor was George Thayer.
|
Mehitabel Livermore was born in 1812 in Vermont. She married first Bela Wetmore (1764-1839) and had a daughter, Harriet, in 1836 (she married Elijah Sells). The Wetmore 85-acre farm was on the west side of Main Street, south of Route 20A, almost opposite (but a bit north of) the Philip Short farm. To the north, next door lived the Presby family. Bela Wetmore’s daughter Lucy married Otis Presby, “the boy next door.”
After Bela’s death, Mehitabel became involved with her neighbor Josiah Short and had three children with him: Julia, James, and Delia. She and her four children moved to Lima in 1851. She later lived with her son James in Winfield (Cawley County), Kansas, where she died April 7, 1886.
|